• New York State, Court of Appeals
  • No. 72
  • Judges Graffeo, Read, Smith, Pigott and Rivera concur. 
Chief Judge Lippman dissents in part in an opinion.
  • For Plaintiff: Ronald L. Kuby, for appellant.
  • For Defendant: Vincent Rivellese, for respondent. National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers et al., amici curiae.
NY Aggravated Harassment Statute Found Unconstitutional