• New York State Court of Appeals
  • No. 98
  • For Each Case: Opinion by Judge Pigott. Chief Judge Lippman and Judges Graffeo, Read, Smith and Rivera concur. Judge Abdus-Salaam took no part.
  • For Plaintiff: Case No. 98: Scott Shorr, for City appellants. Richard Dearing, for State appellants. Stephen L. Saxl, for intervenors-appellants.
  • For Defendant: Case No. 98: Steven G. Mintz, for respondents. Office of the Manhattan Borough President, amicus curiae
Council Wasn't Needed to Pass NYC Taxi Plan, Ruling Concludes